ReplayTake vs Skillest
Skillest is the stronger choice for a full-time sports coach who wants one system for everything: 240 fps analysis, side-by-side, voice-over, scheduling, CRM, courses and a marketplace with 2,500 coaches. Choose ReplayTake when you sell one thing, an asynchronous review of a recording, and want to start without a subscription, keep your own students at a 5% fee, and coach dance or music rather than golf.
| Skillest | ReplayTake | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost to sell | $59/mo | $0; storage plans optional |
| Primary sports | Golf first; baseball, basketball, cricket, swimming | Dance and music first; any recording |
| Video analysis | Up to 240 fps frame-by-frame, drawing, side-by-side, voice-over | Frame step, slow-down, A-B loops, drawing, audio clips on a note; no side-by-side |
| Live lessons and scheduling | Zoom, two-way calendar sync, self-booking | No |
| Messaging and CRM | Threaded per student, voice notes, CRM | Comment threads on the moment; no CRM |
| Courses and subscriptions | Yes | No |
| Marketplace | 2,500+ coaches, 950,000+ lessons claimed | Not yet; your own links |
| What the student keeps | Lessons in the Skillest app | Their own recording with the review pinned to it, loopable at home |
| Fee on your own students | Inside the subscription | 5%, or none if paid outside |
| Price | Coach subscription $59/mo after a 7-day trial; payments through Stripe; lesson fee share not published | Free to publish a page; card orders through ReplayTake keep 5% from your own link or 15% when we brought the student, processing included; orders paid outside carry no fee. Storage plans: Free 2 GB, Plus $9/mo, Studio $19/mo. Students join free. |
Verified on 2026-09-10 against Skillest's pricing page. We re-check each quarter; tell us if something changed.
Choose Skillest if
- You coach golf or another swing sport full time and want scheduling, CRM and courses in one place.
- You need side-by-side comparison and 240 fps capture.
- You want to be listed where sports students already browse.
Choose ReplayTake if
- You want to sell reviews without paying $59 a month first.
- You teach dance or music and the student’s own recording is the lesson.
- You want the review to stay useful after delivery: loops, slower speed, replies.
Founding beta