ReplayTake vs CritiqueMyDance
CritiqueMyDance is the better choice today if you want to be found: it has a public roster of coaches across fourteen dance styles, visible prices, and dancers who already know what a critique is. Choose ReplayTake when the students are yours, you want to keep 95% or more of the price, and you want the critique to live on as a practice workspace, with each correction pinned to the moment, loopable at slower speed, and answerable, rather than a delivered video.
| CritiqueMyDance | ReplayTake | |
|---|---|---|
| Find a coach | Public roster with prices, reviews and disciplines | Not yet: your page and your links, while the founding cohort runs |
| Disciplines | Dance only, fourteen styles | Dance, music, any recording |
| What the student receives | A video with voice-over and on-frame drawing, plus written notes | Their own recording with timestamped notes, drawings, audio clips, loops and top priorities |
| After delivery | Watch the critique video | Loop each corrected moment, slow it down, reply on it; the history stays |
| Voice-over narration | Yes | Audio clips on a note, not a narrated video |
| Turnaround | 24–48 hours stated | Set per product by the expert |
| Who owns the footage | Uploaded into the coach’s queue | The student, in their own library; the expert is an editor |
| Fee on a student you brought | Not published | 5% (card) or nothing (paid outside) |
| Refunds and disputes | Per coach | Written rule: auto-refund on non-delivery |
| Price | Coaches set their own rate; most critiques start around $60, one coach charges $12; coaches keep “the majority of every fee” and the share is not published | Free to publish a page; card orders through ReplayTake keep 5% from your own link or 15% when we brought the student, processing included; orders paid outside carry no fee. Storage plans: Free 2 GB, Plus $9/mo, Studio $19/mo. Students join free. |
Verified on 2026-09-10 against CritiqueMyDance's pricing page. We re-check each quarter; tell us if something changed.
Choose CritiqueMyDance if
- You are a dance coach without students yet and need a marketplace to send them.
- Your students want a narrated critique video they can watch once.
- Dance is all you teach and a dance-only brand helps.
Choose ReplayTake if
- Your students already come to you and you would rather keep the price than pay for discovery.
- You want the correction to become practice: pinned to the moment, loopable, replyable.
- You teach more than one discipline, or coach music as well as dance.
Founding beta